The Verdict

Trespass and Theft of Dogs From a Puppy Factory

Patty Mark pleaded guilty to tresspass and theft (see previous story) with mitigating circumstances in the Kyneton Magistrates Court today, and she managed to keep the focus squarely on the dogs who were grossly neglected and in very poor condition. Defending herself she presented to the Magistrate several photos of the three dogs taken on the day she helped remove them for veterinary care. The Magistrate was visibly moved when looking through the photos.

Patty during the puppy farm rescue

She also handed him a copy of the vet report and told how the dogs were given a rating of only 1 – 1.5 out of 5 for their condition. She read the concluding comments from the vet, “In my professional opinion, the matted and unhygienic state of the coats, the very low body condition scores and the appearance of the dogs’ teeth indicated neglect on the part of the person or persons responsible for their care.  It is also my opinion that without attention to improved care, the health of these three dogs would have been seriously compromised in the foreseeable future.”

Patty explained that she had a deep respect for the law, but after working non-stop for the past thirty years none of the ‘legal authorities’ as proscribed in Section 24 Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act (who are the Police, RSPCA, Minister for Agriculture and the Local Council) had taken even one case to court from the countless complaints and appeals she lodged with them. Patty strongly emphasised to the court that the current system was failing and the majority of animals in Victoria were without protection. The Magistrate showed some sympathy, but was bound by the law and obliged by parity (with a prior co-defendant) to fine Ms Mark $750 and record a conviction.


Oscar/Chai at the vets

Patty then stated she refused to pay fines for taking sick, injured and/or neglected animals to a vet for treatment. Patty has eight warrants out for her imprisonment for unpaid fines of this nature going back 12 years.  She made it clear to the Magistrate that she wouldn’t be paying this fine either. The Magistrate said that was up to her and gave her one month to pay, then said, “You are free to leave the court”.

So whereas Patty now has multiple convictions of trespass and theft going back many years, the ‘verdict’ is obvious sympathy for the actions she is taking as no Magistrate is willing to jail her after seeing the pitiful images of the rescued animals.  More importantly perhaps, the ‘property status’ of animals is slowly but surely being questioned in the courtroom.  Had Patty been ‘stealing’ cars, jewelry or wads of money over the years there is no way she would not be sitting in a jail cell tonight.

Patty would like to thank the 25 people who traveled to the Kyneton to support all the dogs locked away in puppy factories as well as the many people who sent messages of support.


  • Jacqui Campbell - 6 June, 2011

    To ALV,
    I am lost for words. When i read the article about Oscar i initially thought it was a joke (that he was handed back to the authorities). Days later i have read this aticle and relieze that it was for real. They really let him go back there . . . ? I still do not understand that. Might as well of put a bullet to his head than send him back there. How can they do that? Who takes responsability for that? I do not understand any of this. The human race is suppose to be an intelligent species … We have lawyers, politicians and people in ‘high up’ positions who do not know how to use their ‘power’ in a humane way. Where is there humility? Where is there humanity? Where is there clarity of thought in these problems?…
    I volunteered at an animal shelter today. I volunteered at an animal shelter today. Over the weekend thay had thirteen dogs handed over from a ‘dog farm’. The owners of these dogs had apparently asked the farmer next door to ‘kill them’. Obviously he didn’t as they were at the shelter and hopefully all will be rehomed. I just feel deeply saddened that they have spent there lives being breeding machines and now the owner wants to pays his/her respects to this ‘livestock’ by having them killed. Where is his/her sense of compassion or empathy or anything…
    Thank you for all the work you do.
    Jacqui Campbell

Leave a comment